Tottenham Hotspur vs Everton Prediction: Premier League Matchweek 4 Picks (Sept 12, 2026)

By Cole Gallagher / August 18, 2026

Premier League · Sept 12, 2026 · Tottenham Hotspur Stadium, London · 5:30 PM BST / 12:30 PM ET

⚽ Tottenham Hotspur vs Everton ⚽

TOTTENHAM HOTSPUR
EVERTON

Premier League books post lines closer to kickoff. Check back nearer kickoff for a live number.

Tottenham Hotspur host Everton at the Tottenham Hotspur Stadium in a Matchweek 4 clash that gives Roberto De Zerbi his first look at a David Moyes side that has spent big to reshape itself this summer. De Zerbi is in his first full preseason in permanent charge of Spurs after taking the job on a permanent basis at the end of March, while Moyes has overseen what he himself called the busiest transfer window of his managerial career at Everton. Here is our full breakdown, part of our ongoing coverage of the top betting sites for backing every Premier League fixture this season.

Odds Comparison

Sportsbook Tottenham Hotspur Draw Everton
Sports Interaction Check Odds → Check Odds → Check Odds →
Betovo Check Odds → Check Odds → Check Odds →
Bet365 Check Odds → Check Odds → Check Odds →
Tonybet Check Odds → Check Odds → Check Odds →
Betway Check Odds → Check Odds → Check Odds →

Both Teams to Score

Check Now →

Total Goals

Check Now →

Team Analysis

Tottenham Hotspur

De Zerbi is still trying to fully stamp his possession-based identity on this Spurs squad after missing out on two notable summer targets, Eberechi Eze and, notably, Nottingham Forest’s Morgan Gibbs-White. Working with largely the same attacking pieces as before means the early matchweeks have doubled as a live audition for exactly how De Zerbi wants his Tottenham side to play, and a home fixture against a fellow London-adjacent rival in Everton is another data point in that process.

Key Storyline: Roberto De Zerbi continues building his identity at Spurs after missing out on both Eze and a run at Morgan Gibbs-White over the summer

Everton

David Moyes called this the busiest transfer window of his managerial career, and the incoming list backs that up: Tyrique George arrived from Chelsea, Hayden Hackney joined from Middlesbrough, and Brennan Johnson came in as part of a swap deal that sent Dwight McNeil to Crystal Palace. Even after all that activity, Moyes said publicly he still wanted “quite a few” more additions before the September 1 deadline. Injuries have not helped, with midfielders James Garner and Tim Iroegbunam both missing the season opener and centre-backs James Tarkowski and Jarrod Branthwaite carrying their own fitness question marks. Everton finished 13th last season and will see a trip to north London as a fair measure of the progress Moyes is building.

Key Storyline: David Moyes’ busiest transfer window as a manager gets tested on the road against a Tottenham side still finding its own attacking rhythm

Key Betting Angles

Tottenham have dominated this fixture historically, winning close to half of the 60 Premier League meetings between these clubs compared to a small fraction of wins for Everton, and last season’s meeting went the way of the home side 3-2. Everton’s summer spending gives Moyes more attacking talent than usual to trouble that record, but the midfield and defensive injuries make it hard to trust them controlling a game at this level. We would lean toward Spurs at home, with the goals markets worth a look given the attacking talent Everton can call on even while missing key pieces.

We are tracking the full Premier League Matchweek 4 slate, plus everything else on the board, over on worldcupbetting.ca.

Our Prediction

Cole’s Pick: Tottenham Hotspur to win

Tottenham’s home record in this fixture and De Zerbi’s growing familiarity with his squad give the hosts the edge, even with the Eze and Gibbs-White misses still lingering as questions. Everton’s summer investment makes them a tougher out than in recent visits to north London, and with Garner, Iroegbunam, Tarkowski and Branthwaite all carrying fitness concerns, we like Spurs to make home advantage count without expecting a one-sided game.

Confidence: medium, backed by Tottenham’s strong recent head-to-head record in this exact fixture

Best Bets

Top Pick

Tottenham Hotspur to Win

Check the latest line here →

Value Bet

Both Teams to Score

Check the latest line here →

Longshot

Everton to Win

Check the latest line here →

Latest Predictions

19+. Gambling can be addictive. If you or someone you know needs support, visit ProblemGambling.ca or call ConnexOntario at 1-866-531-2600.