Newcastle United vs Everton Prediction: Premier League Matchweek 9 Picks (Nov 2, 2026)

By Cole Gallagher / October 19, 2026

Premier League · Matchweek 9 · Nov 2, 2026 · St James’ Park, Newcastle · 3:00 PM ET / 8:00 PM GMT

⚽ Newcastle United vs Everton ⚽

NEWCASTLE UNITED
EVERTON

Premier League books post lines closer to kickoff. Check back nearer kickoff for a live number.

St James’ Park closes out Matchweek 9 on Monday night as Newcastle United host Everton in front of a passionate home crowd. Here is our full breakdown, part of our ongoing coverage of the best sportsbooks for backing every Premier League fixture this season.

Odds Comparison

Sportsbook Newcastle United Draw Everton
Sports Interaction Check Odds → Check Odds → Check Odds →
Betovo Check Odds → Check Odds → Check Odds →
Bet365 Check Odds → Check Odds → Check Odds →
Tonybet Check Odds → Check Odds → Check Odds →
Betway Check Odds → Check Odds → Check Odds →

Both Teams to Score

Check Now →

Total Goals

Check Now →

Team Analysis

Newcastle United

Newcastle United are a powerful side at St James’ Park, where the roar of the crowd fuels their intense, physical style. They press with energy and carry genuine quality in attack, making them a handful for any visitor. At home they typically take the initiative and look to overwhelm opponents with their intensity. The atmosphere on a Monday night under the lights can be particularly intimidating. Their blend of power and quality makes them strong favourites on their own ground.

Key Storyline: Newcastle will aim to harness a charged home crowd and impose their intensity from the start.

Everton

Everton are a resilient, well-organised side with a proud tradition and a combative edge. Away from home they tend to prioritise defensive solidity and look to frustrate stronger hosts. Their physicality and willingness to compete make them awkward opponents even in hostile venues. Their forward players can be dangerous on the counter if space opens up. They will travel to St James’ Park intent on staying compact and taking their chances.

Key Storyline: Everton will look to dig in, stay organised and hit Newcastle on the break.

Key Betting Angles

Backing the hosts to make their home intensity count is the leading angle here. A Newcastle clean sheet is worth weighing given Everton’s cautious away approach. Both teams to score is less certain if the visitors sit deep and limit their own ambition. The goals total could depend on how much Everton commit forward. Markets favouring the home side asserting control look the most logical.

We are tracking the full Premier League Matchweek 9 slate, plus everything else on the board, over on worldcupbetting.ca.

Our Prediction

Cole’s Pick: Newcastle United to win

Newcastle’s home intensity and attacking quality give them a clear edge against a cautious visitor. Everton are well organised and capable of frustrating, which could keep the margin tight. The hosts’ power and the St James’ Park atmosphere should ultimately see them through.

Confidence: medium, Newcastle are strong at home against a defensive visitor

Best Bets

Top Pick

Newcastle United to Win

Check the latest line here →

Value Bet

Under 2.5 Goals

Check the latest line here →

Longshot

Draw No Bet

Check the latest line here →

Latest Predictions

19+. Gambling can be addictive. If you or someone you know needs support, visit ProblemGambling.ca or call ConnexOntario at 1-866-531-2600.